The latest graphic novel by the extremely talented Raina Telgemeier is a true treat. I loved that the main character is of Mexican heritage, and the story explores the ways in which their family has lost touch with Mexican traditions after the death of Abuela (Grandma). This story shares with readers what it is like to have a sick sibling and it explains cystic fibrosis in an empathetic, kid-friendly way. The theme of ghosts and celebrating the loved ones we have lost through the holiday of Dia de los Muertos was well done and touching. This title will make a great addition to my classroom library, and I know my students will love it. I recommend this book to fans of graphic novels and Raina Telgemeier, as well as kids who feel like their siblings' needs may overshadow their own. Kids who have recently moved and had to change schools will also identify with main character, Catrina.
We need more books for adolescents about the experience of young illegal immigrants living in the United States, and the struggles they face. After my students suggested La Linea by Ann Jaramillo, I've been looking for similar books. I was very hopeful when I picked up Restrepo's book. While some parts of it will be relatable and compelling for certain students, I thought it was slightly unrealistic and did not delve into the true struggles that many immigrant youth face. The main character, Nora, and her mother seem to "luck out" and fare better than I expect most people do. Illegal is worth reading, but I had hoped for more. I'd recommend it to a younger middle school audience, or to more idealistic, naive readers since other students might see right through the hopeful, glossy perspective this book takes on a serious, complex topic.
